Questions to Ask in a Phone Screen (Template Included)

Questions to Ask in a Phone Screen (Template Included)

Questions to Ask in a Phone Screen (Template Included)

Written by

Daniel Kunz

I

Published on

I

6

MIN

Vintage phone receiver hanging on a light background representing a candidate phone screen call

Running the Unsplash query now. Paste this in your browser:

https://api.unsplash.com/search/photos?query=phone+call+headset+bright+office&per_page=5&client_id=NNUuT01sLy_7x747pqQ-fs_dPHdOCZIh8CcjR6qXc54

And here's Article 4:

1. Category: Interview Questions

2. Reading time: 6 min

3. Title: Questions to Ask in a Phone Screen (Template Included)

4. Excerpt: A good phone screen tells you in 25 minutes whether to move a candidate forward. Here's the question template to use, what to listen for, and what to skip.

5. SEO title: Phone Screen Interview Questions: Template & Examples | Oryx

6. SEO description: The essential questions to ask in a phone screen, in the right order, with what to listen for. A practical template you can use for your next screening call.

7. Slug: phone-screen-questions

8. Content:

Questions to Ask in a Phone Screen (Template Included)

A phone screen has one job: decide whether to move this candidate forward.

Not hire them. Not evaluate them comprehensively. Just answer one question: is this person worth a longer conversation with the hiring manager? That's it.

Most phone screens fail because they try to do too much. They drift into full behavioral interviews, they let the candidate talk for 20 minutes about their resume, they end with the screener having no clearer answer than they started with. A good phone screen is sharp, focused, and gets you to a yes or no in 25 to 30 minutes.

Here's the template to use, the questions that matter, and what to listen for.

Before the call: the five things to know

Don't show up cold. Spend five minutes before the call answering these for yourself.

  • What's the role, really? Not just the title. What problem is this hire solving?

  • What are the three non-negotiable must-haves?

  • What's the compensation range?

  • What are the realistic deal-breakers? Location, work permit, notice period, compensation expectations?

  • What does the hiring manager actually want to know that you can only learn on a call?

If you can't answer these quickly, you're not ready to screen. Go back and align with the hiring manager first.

The phone screen structure (30 minutes)

Here's the structure I'd recommend, with time allocations. Deviate based on role, but this is a solid default.

  • Minutes 1-3: Welcome, brief intro, frame the call

  • Minutes 4-10: Candidate's background (tight, not an autobiography)

  • Minutes 11-20: Two or three core screening questions

  • Minutes 21-27: Role overview and candidate's questions

  • Minutes 28-30: Next steps and close

The single biggest mistake is letting the candidate's background section eat 20 minutes. Keep it tight.

Opening the call (3 minutes)

Set the tone. Be warm but structured.

What to say: "Thanks for making time. Quick overview of how I'd like to use the next 30 minutes: I'll ask you a bit about your background and what you're looking for, then I'll give you an overview of the role and the company, then we'll leave time for your questions. Sound good?"

Why this matters: Candidates often expect an unstructured conversation. Framing the call upfront gives you permission to steer it and manage time. It also signals competence, which matters for candidate experience.

Candidate background (7 minutes)

This is where phone screens derail. Candidates will happily spend 15 minutes walking you through every job on their resume. Don't let them.

What to ask:

  • "Can you walk me through the last two or three roles you've had and what you're looking for next?"

That's it. One question, seven minutes. Not "tell me about yourself." That's too open.

What to listen for:

  • Clarity about what they're looking for

  • Coherence of career trajectory

  • Whether they're reactively job hunting or proactively pursuing something

  • Signals about why they're leaving their current role

How to keep it tight: If the candidate starts their career story ten years ago, interrupt politely: "Let me actually skip ahead to your most recent role, we've got a lot to cover." Don't apologize for this. It's your call to run.

Core screening questions (10 minutes)

Two or three questions, not six. Pick them based on what you genuinely need to know to decide whether to move forward.

These are the three most useful phone screen questions for most roles.

Question 1: "What specifically drew you to this role?"

The goal here is to understand how much the candidate has engaged with the specific opportunity versus applying broadly. Strong candidates reference specific things from the job description, mention the company's work, or articulate why this role fits their career direction. Weak candidates give generic "I'm looking for a new challenge" answers that could apply to any job.

What to listen for: Specificity. Has the candidate actually thought about why this role, or are they throwing applications at the wall?

Question 2: "Tell me about a recent project or piece of work you're proud of and what you specifically did."

This is your main signal question for whether they can actually do the work. It's a behavioral question disguised as a softball. You're testing whether they can articulate specifics, take personal ownership, and describe real impact.

What to listen for: Concrete examples, clear articulation of their specific role, and a realistic sense of what was hard. Weak candidates describe team outcomes without showing what they did. Strong candidates can answer "what did you specifically do?" without hesitation.

Question 3: "What's important to you in your next role?"

The goal is to understand motivations and check for alignment with the role. If someone says "flexibility and remote work" and your role is fully on-site, you both save time by surfacing that now. If someone says "technical depth" and your role is heavily managerial, that's a mismatch.

What to listen for: Honesty. Candidates who give you the "right" answer to fit your role aren't being authentic. You want what they'd tell a friend over coffee.

Role overview (4 minutes)

Once you're comfortable moving the candidate forward, give them the role overview. Don't do this first. Why? Because candidates will shape their answers around what they think you want to hear. Give them the pitch after you've assessed them.

Keep it tight. Cover:

  • What the role actually involves day to day

  • Who they'd report to and the team structure

  • Why the role exists

  • What success looks like in the first 90 days

  • Compensation range

Be honest about the role's challenges too. Candidates who hear only the glossy version show up to later rounds misaligned. A good screener mentions at least one real challenge of the role.

Candidate's questions (3 minutes)

The questions candidates ask tell you a lot. Strong candidates ask specific, informed questions about the role, the team, and the company. Weak candidates either don't have questions or ask things they could have googled.

Questions that are good signals: Questions about how decisions are made, what the first 90 days look like, what the biggest challenges are, what the last person in this role struggled with.

Questions that are weak signals: Questions about basic company information, pre-obvious questions like "what's the culture like," or no questions at all.

Close the call (3 minutes)

Always end the call with a clear next step.

What to say: "Thanks for the time. Here's what happens next: [specific next step, specific timing]. If for any reason I need more time, I'll email you by [specific day]. Does that work?"

Never leave with vague language like "we'll be in touch." That's the single biggest candidate experience killer in early-stage interviews.

If you already know the candidate isn't a fit, you can close with "I don't think this is going to be the right match, but I wanted to be direct with you rather than leave you waiting. Do you mind if I share why?" Most candidates will respect this, and some will give you useful feedback for future searches.

Additional screening questions to use when relevant

These are useful but not always needed. Pull one in when the context calls for it.

  • "What's your current compensation range, and what are you looking for?" — Always ask early if compensation fit is a risk.

  • "What's your notice period?" — Important for timeline planning.

  • "Are you interviewing anywhere else? Where are you in those processes?" — Gives you a sense of urgency and competitive context.

  • "Is there anything about your background you think I should understand?" — Opens space for the candidate to address red flags like gaps or recent moves.

  • "Anything you want to ask me that might be a deal-breaker?" — Good for surfacing issues like remote work expectations early.

What to skip on a phone screen

Some questions are fine in later rounds but a poor use of time in a 30-minute screening call.

Skip behavioral deep-dives. These are for the hiring manager. You're deciding whether to hand the candidate over, not conducting a full assessment.

Skip "tell me about yourself." Too open. You'll lose 15 minutes.

Skip "what's your biggest weakness." Produces rehearsed non-answers. Phone screen time is too valuable.

Skip hypothetical puzzles. Save situational and behavioral questions for structured interview rounds.

Skip company culture questions. These belong later in the process when the candidate has enough context to ask substantive follow-ups.

The phone screen decision framework

At the end of the call, you should be able to answer three questions.

  • Could this person do the job? (Skills fit)

  • Do they genuinely want this role? (Motivation fit)

  • Are there any deal-breakers? (Compensation, location, timing)

If yes to the first two and no deal-breakers: advance. If one of the first two is a clear no: decline. If you're genuinely unsure: advance with a note, or schedule a short follow-up call before deciding.

Build it into a repeatable guide

The fastest way to get consistent phone screens across hires is to use the same questions, in the same order, with the same scoring approach for every candidate. That's the core idea of a [structured interview], and it starts from the first call.

Run better interviews. Make better hires.

Run better interviews. Make better hires.

Affordable hiring software.

For growing teams.

Affordable hiring software.

For growing teams.

Affordable hiring software.

For growing teams.